Two houses on Calusa Street sold this summer. The first, 2777 Calusa St, is a 1947 house with 765 square feet of interior space. It sold for $3.1 million, which works out to $4,052 per square foot. The second, 2800 Calusa St, was finished in 2025 and has 6,393 square feet. It sold for $8.1 million, or $1,267 per square foot. Both sales are in Haute Residence's Q3 2026 Coconut Grove report, which lists every recorded residential sale of $2 million or more in ZIP 33133, excluding records labeled Coral Gables, with sale dates from July 1 to September 30, 2026.
The older house sold for more than three times as much per square foot as the new one. In our reading, a price like that reflects the value of the Calusa Street lot much more than the 1947 house on it. That is the main thing to understand if you're comparing Coconut Grove with other neighborhoods. Once an older Grove house is small enough, its price says more about the land than about the house.
The smallest houses carry the highest price per foot
The pattern runs through the whole quarter, not just Calusa Street. Across all 57 recorded sales of $2 million and up in Q3 2026, the weighted average was $1,435 per square foot. Many of the smallest prewar and postwar houses came in far above that average, and most of the recently built homes came in at or below it.
| Address | Year built | Interior sq ft | Q3 2026 sale | Per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2777 Calusa St | 1947 | 765 | $3,100,000 | $4,052 |
| 3170 Florida Ave | 1944 | 1,088 | $3,120,000 | $2,868 |
| 4152 Battersea Rd | 1947 | 1,810 | $4,475,000 | $2,472 |
| 2980 Bird Ave | 1922 | 1,064 | $2,100,000 | $1,974 |
| 2490 Abaco Ave | 1940 | 1,059 | $2,000,000 | $1,889 |
| 215 Shore Dr S | 2025 | 4,626 | $6,500,000 | $1,405 |
| 4095 Hardie Ave | 2025 | 3,874 | $5,000,000 | $1,291 |
| 2800 Calusa St | 2025 | 6,393 | $8,100,000 | $1,267 |
| 2175 SW 25th St | 2025 | 3,679 | $2,790,000 | $758 |
Two houses on Abaco Avenue show the same thing at a smaller scale. 2490 and 2496 Abaco Ave were both built in 1940, and the report lists the same sale date for both, August 26. One sold for $2.0 million and the other for $2.7 million. They are on the same street, were built in the same year and sold on the same listed date, and still sold $700,000 apart. Price per foot can't account for a gap like that, because differences between the two lots are part of it. For a cottage, the price-per-foot figure on a listing sheet tells you little about the house itself.
What the finished product sells for
If the older houses mark the floor for land, the 2025-built homes show what builders can sell once the work is done. The top sale of the quarter was 4040 Kiaora St, a 2025 home of 8,548 square feet, which sold for $22.5 million, or $2,632 per square foot, recorded August 4, 2026. Profile Miami reported that Sabal Development's construction arm, Sabal Luxury Builder, designed and built the house. Below that, the new homes at 2800 Calusa St, 215 Shore Dr S and 4095 Hardie Ave sold for between $5 million and $8.1 million in the same quarter.
Put the two halves of the table together and you can see where the competition comes from. A family looking at a 1,000-square-foot cottage at $2 million to $3 million is competing with buyers who see the same lot as the first step toward a $5 million to $8 million house. Coconut Grove Spotlight reported in November that a local agent described the situation directly: sellers who want the highest and best price usually end up with a developer who plans to tear down the whole structure. So even if you plan to live in the cottage, expect to pay a price set partly by what a builder would offer for the lot. Price your offer that way, and judge the house by what it lets you do with the lot.
A third option between keeping and rebuilding
The usual choice is between living in the old house as it is and replacing it. A Grove firm has been building a third option. The same Coconut Grove Spotlight article profiles TROPICA, an architecture and landscaping firm founded in the Grove in 2019. TROPICA is designing and rebuilding nine cottages from the 1920s to the 1940s across the North, South and Center Grove.
The firm's pilot project is in the North Grove. It is a 1925 cottage of just 825 square feet, restored and joined to a 7,000-square-foot addition built in a matching style. In another project, a century-old Spanish-style stucco cottage in Center Grove, the new design takes the roof off the original living room, keeps its coral rock fireplace, and turns that room into a courtyard at the center of a larger home. A Swanson Avenue project keeps the front of the original cottage and traces the outline of the rest onto the concrete walls of the addition.
The numbers matter here. According to the Spotlight, TROPICA rebuilds average $500 to $800 per square foot. The same article cites Levy Builders' estimate that luxury custom new construction in Miami starts at $350 to $650 per square foot. Restoring and expanding costs more per foot to build, and the North Grove pilot took years of design work. The other side, as the Spotlight reported, is that agents expect a well-restored cottage could eventually sell for more per square foot than a new build. For a buyer, a cottage priced at lot value has a fair price under any of three plans: keep it, expand around it, or replace it. Your budget and your timeline decide which plan makes sense.
The trees decide part of the timeline
Whichever plan you choose, the lot comes with its canopy, and in 2026 the canopy has become part of the schedule. Coconut Grove Spotlight reported in May that neighbors on Irvington Avenue in the South Grove challenged the planned removal of a 52-foot live oak, 30 inches in diameter, that had been marked for removal to make room for a new home. A Spotlight viewpoint in August noted that the City of Miami's Historic and Environmental Preservation Board reversed tree-removal permits on El Prado Boulevard and Swanson Avenue after residents challenged them.
In November, the Spotlight reported that Miami's Tree Ordinance Advisory Committee is expected to send recommendations to the City Commission by March. The same article said some challenges in the Grove have ended in negotiated agreements to preserve or relocate trees. For a buyer weighing a cottage, the large trees on a lot belong in the plan from the first walk-through, along with the house and the budget.
Reading a Grove listing with this in mind
Once you see an older cottage as a lot, the questions you ask change. Price per square foot stops being useful, so compare the asking price with recent cottage sales on nearby streets, not with the quarter's averages. The year a house was built tells you less than the lot and what it can hold. The condition of the house matters mostly because it shows whether keeping it or expanding around it is realistic, as the owners in TROPICA's projects decided. The 2025-built sales on Calusa, Hardie and Shore Drive South give you the other end of the math: what a finished new home has actually sold for, on recorded deeds, in the same quarter.
If you're still deciding whether the Grove suits you, our Coconut Grove neighborhood page covers the area more broadly. Our recent look at Saturdays on Grand Avenue's new Main Street shows what weekends are like there. If you're comparing the Grove's condo market instead, start with Coconut Grove or Coral Gables condos.
A few questions buyers ask
Is a $3 million cottage in Coconut Grove overpriced? Not by Q3 2026 standards. Between July 1 and September 30, 2026, the 765-square-foot 1947 house at 2777 Calusa St sold for $3.1 million, and the 1,088-square-foot 1944 house at 3170 Florida Ave sold for $3.12 million. Prices like those largely reflect land, so compare a cottage with other cottage sales, not with new homes.
Do new homes in the Grove cost more per square foot than old ones? In Q3 2026, mostly no. Most 2025-built homes on the recorded list sold for between $758 and $1,405 per square foot, while several cottages sold for more than $1,800. The exception was 4040 Kiaora St at $2,632 per square foot.
Is restoring an old cottage cheaper than building new? Per square foot, it usually costs more. The Spotlight reported TROPICA's rebuilds at $500 to $800 per square foot, compared with Levy Builders' $350 to $650 estimate for luxury custom construction.
If you own a Grove cottage and wonder whether a buyer will see a house or a lot, or you're house-hunting and want to know what a particular lot is worth before you make an offer, the Gilman Group can go through recent sales on your street with you. Start with a free home valuation and we'll take it from there together.